Key points
1You can't give what you don't have
Pastor Joshua opens with a personal story from his first Christmas as a newlywed, when he punched a picture frame in anger after coming home to find the Christmas tree moved. His wife forgave him without him earning it, teaching him that he couldn't offer peace or grace because he wasn't carrying it himself.
You can't give what you don't have
2Forgiveness is rooted in what Christ has done for us, not in what happened to us
Reading Colossians 3:13, he points out the text never conditions forgiveness on an apology, deserving it, or feeling ready — it simply says forgive, because we were forgiven first.
Forgiveness is only needed when it's undeserved
You cannot earn forgiveness. It has to be freely given
3Forgiveness is not denying, forgetting, controlling, or reconciling
He unpacks four common misunderstandings: forgiveness doesn't mean pretending something didn't happen, erasing it, controlling the narrative or waiting for an apology, or requiring reconciliation with the offender. He quotes another pastor's line that if a cycle is predictable, it's preventable, since healing can't happen while still living in the cycle.
4Forgiveness is debt-free, ongoing, undeserving, and freeing
Using Colossians 2:13, he shows God didn't reduce our debt but canceled it entirely. Using Matthew 18:21-22 and the Peter story, he shows forgiveness has no numerical limit since Jesus paid it eternally. Using Titus 3:5 he shows forgiveness is mercy, not a reward, and using Matthew 6:14 and modern research from Stanford, Johns Hopkins, and University of Wisconsin, he shows unforgiveness harms us while forgiveness frees us.
if the cycle is predictable, then the cycle is preventable
The extent to which though we choose to be unforgiving often reveals the extent to which we don't understand forgiveness ourselves
Illustration
Studies from Stanford University, Johns Hopkins, and the University of Wisconsin correlating unforgiveness with higher stress and illness, and forgiveness with better mental health and well-being
5Jesus modeled forgiveness as a choice, not a feeling, from the cross
He points to Luke 23, where Jesus, while being mocked and killed, prayed 'Father, forgive them,' proving forgiveness is a decision made even without the feeling of readiness.
forgiveness isn't just biblical, it's beneficial
6His own story of tragedy, counseling, and prison ministry showed him forgiveness sets you free
He shares that in 2017 his family faced a devastating loss he didn't handle well, leading him to a week-long counseling intensive he hated but that changed him. The next month, God placed him in prison ministry, where he realized he had no choice but to extend the same forgiveness to others that Jesus had extended to him.
A story from life
Pastor Joshua Paul describes a devastating family crisis in August 2017, eight months of struggling to cope, a week-long faith-based counseling intensive in Florida, and a subsequent prison ministry experience in April 2018 that crystallized his understanding of forgiveness
A story from life
Pastor Joshua Paul recounts a volatile moment in his first Christmas as a newlywed — punching a picture frame over a moved Christmas tree — and his wife's unexpected forgiveness, which he frames as a picture of Christ's grace
Application
Pastor Joshua frames the response as three moves: receive forgiveness from God, give forgiveness to others, and give forgiveness to yourself.
Receive forgiveness from God first
Recognize forgiveness has nothing to do with your own goodness or deeds; it's mercy alone, so start by simply receiving it if you never have.
Give forgiveness to others who hurt you
Choose to stop paying back evil with evil and let go of what someone owes you, even though it does not mean trusting them again or pretending what happened was okay.
Give forgiveness to yourself
If you've mentally accepted God's forgiveness but still carry guilt in your heart, choose to stop replaying what God has already put behind you, since there is no condemnation for those in Christ.
Ask yourself the hard questions
Sit with the questions: what are you still holding on to, who do you need to forgive, what do you need to release, and where do you need to forgive yourself?
Take it into your week
Rewind AI contributed study material from the sermon transcript; church-authored wording and verified sermon quotes keep their own source. Always trust the sermon itself over anything here. How Rewind uses AI